Influence of Customary Law in the Nigerian Legal System

Last Updated on January 27, 2024

Introduction

Customary law refers to the unwritten laws and practices that have been passed down by communities over generations. It is an integral part of Nigeria’s legal system as it plays a significant role in resolving disputes and maintaining societal norms.

The importance of customary law cannot be overstated as it is deeply rooted in Nigeria’s cultural and religious traditions.

Understanding the influence of customary law in the Nigerian legal system is critical as it sheds light on the interplay between traditional and formal legal systems.

The legal system of any country cannot operate in a vacuum, and the Nigerian system is no exception. Nigeria’s legal system is a hybrid of statutory law and customary law.

Customary law in Nigeria covers a wide range of areas, including family law, land law, and criminal law.

The interplay between customary and formal legal systems in Nigeria has given rise to several legal challenges.

The Nigerian Constitution acknowledges the existence of customary law and recognizes it as part of the country’s legal system. However, the relationship between customary law and the formal legal system in Nigeria is a contentious issue.

In discussing the influence of customary law on the Nigerian legal system, it is crucial to explore the ways in which customary law has shaped and continues to shape legal processes and practices in the country.

This blog chapter will examine the various ways in which customary law influences legal decision-making in Nigeria and highlights the areas where customary law is highly relevant in Nigeria’s legal system.

Overall, understanding the interplay between customary law and the Nigerian legal system is vital for anyone seeking to understand the country’s legal culture.

Read: Environmental Laws in Nigeria: Protecting Nature’s Rights

What is Customary Law?

Customary law governs group behavior through unwritten traditional rules and practices passed down orally, by rituals, and practices.

The community and its leaders enforce it alongside state and federal law. In Nigeria, various customary laws exist for different ethnic groups.

Islamic law applies to Muslims and covers marriage, divorce, and inheritance. Yoruba customary law focuses on family relationships and land ownership, while Igbo customary law emphasizes dispute resolution by village elders and chiefs.

Customary law regulates behaviors, enables amicable dispute resolution, but can discriminate against women and conflict with other laws.

The Nigerian government integrates customary law into the legal system by incorporating elements into state and federal law and recognizing traditional rulers and community leaders.

It remains an important aspect in regulating behavior and resolving disputes, with ongoing efforts towards integration and recognition.

Read: Intellectual Property Rights Law in Nigeria Explained

Importance of Customary Law in the Nigerian Legal System

1. Customary law is a source of law in Nigeria and recognized by the Nigerian legal system.
   
   
2. Customary law is applied in instances where it is not in conflict with the Constitution
   
   
3. Customary law helps to uphold cultural values which are an important aspect of Nigeria’s history.

Customary law is an integral part of Nigeria’s legal system.

Nigeria’s legal system integrates customary law as an integral part and recognizes it as a valid source of law.

Customary law encompasses the customs and traditions of Nigeria’s diverse ethnic groups, with over 250 ethnic groups preserving their unique heritage through generational transmission.

Customary law is applied in cases concerning property rights, inheritance, marriage, and other family matters. It is also used in resolving disputes between individuals and communities. In these instances, the courts will apply customary law as long as it is not in conflict with the Constitution.

Customary law has played an important role in upholding cultural values in Nigeria. Nigeria is a country with a rich cultural heritage, and customary law has helped to preserve this heritage. Customary law ensures that the customs and traditions of the various ethnic groups in Nigeria are respected and upheld.

Customary law has also helped to promote peace and harmony in Nigeria. Disputes between individuals and communities are resolved using customary law, which ensures that the outcome is satisfactory to all parties involved. This has helped to prevent conflicts and has promoted peaceful coexistence between the various ethnic groups in Nigeria.

In general, customary law is an important aspect of Nigeria’s legal system. It is recognized as a source of law and is applied in instances where it is not in conflict with the Constitution. Customary law helps to uphold cultural values, promote peace, and prevent conflicts. It is a valuable aspect of Nigeria’s history and heritage, and it should be preserved and respected.

Read: Nigeria’s Fight Against Corruption: Law’s Critical Role

The Dichotomy between Customary Law and the Nigerian Legal System

Customary law has long been integral to the Nigerian legal system’s administration of justice. However, challenges arise from the dichotomy between customary law and the Nigerian legal system.

These challenges include the absence of uniformity and codification of customary laws, the need to reconcile customary law with written laws, and concerns regarding the protection of fundamental human rights.

1. One of the main challenges faced by the Nigerian legal system in incorporating customary law is the lack of uniformity and codification of customary laws. Customary laws are based on ethnic or cultural differences, and they often vary from one community to another.
   
   
2. Another challenge is the difficulty in reconciling customary law with the written laws. There are instances where customary laws conflict with the written laws, and it is not clear which one should prevail. This creates confusion in the legal system and raises concerns about consistency and fairness.
   
   
3. The Nigerian legal system also faces challenges in incorporating customary law due to the concerns over the protection of fundamental human rights. There are instances where customary laws may discriminate against women or other vulnerable groups, which violates their human rights.

The role of the constitution in addressing the dichotomy between customary law and the Nigerian legal system cannot be overemphasized.

The Constitution acknowledges the significance of customary law in administering justice as a source of Nigerian law. However, it also mandates the consideration of fundamental human rights when applying customary law.

1. The Constitution’s Section 42 prohibits discrimination based on gender, race, religion, or ethnic origin, ensuring the non-discriminatory application of customary law and adherence to human rights principles.
   
   
2. Federal and state legislatures have also enacted laws to address the dichotomy between customary law and the Nigerian legal system. For example, the Lagos State Customary Court Law provides for the establishment of customary courts to administer customary law, subject to the Constitution and written laws of the state.

Despite the efforts made to incorporate customary law into the Nigerian legal system, some argue against its application.

The arguments include:

1. Customary laws lack constitutionality as the legislature does not enact them, and they do not adhere to due process principles.
   
   
2. Customary laws discriminate and infringe upon fundamental human rights, including the right to a fair hearing and property ownership.
   
   
3. The application of customary law is often inconsistent and unpredictable, which undermines the rule of law.

Incorporating customary law into the Nigerian legal system requires a comprehensive approach, ensuring codification, uniformity, and protection of fundamental human rights.

The dichotomy between customary law and the Nigerian legal system poses challenges. The Constitution and legislative efforts effectively address the dichotomy, but a comprehensive approach is necessary to guarantee codification, uniformity, and consistency in applying customary law while safeguarding human rights.

The Influence of Customary Law in Nigerian Jurisprudence

Customary law is an integral part of Nigerian jurisprudence, and its influence is evident in various aspects of the country’s legal system. Here are some case law examples that show the reach of customary law in Nigerian jurisprudence:

1. The Supreme Court ruled in Eke v Nweke that customary law prevails over Islamic law in land ownership disputes in Enugu State.
   
   
2. The Court of Appeal in Alhaji Yusuf v Mufutau Olaluwoye & Ors established that the customary law of the marriage location, not the parties’ domicile or the country where the dispute is heard, applies in matrimonial disputes.
   
   
3. Similarly, in the famous Odua Investment Co. Ltd. v. Talabi case, the Supreme Court upheld Yoruba tribe’s customary law principles on land possession and allocation, even though the dispute occurred in Lagos State, which has its own land laws.

Although the influence of customary law in Nigeria’s legal system is significant, it is not absolute, and statutory law can sometimes conflict with customs.

Read: The Evolution and History of Legal Professions in Nigeria

Here are some examples of the intersection between customary and statutory law:

1. The Nigerian Constitution recognizes and protects customary law in its provisions but also makes it subject to constitutional provisions. In other words, no customary law can contradict the Constitution or any other law of the country.
   
   
2. Statutory law may prescribe some basic requirements that customary law must meet before it can be enforced by a court, such as being consistent with public policy, not being discriminatory, and not conflicting with any relevant legislation.
   
   
3. The Nigerian Evidence Act recognizes customary law as a source of evidence but also prescribes basic rules for the admissibility of evidence in court, including the principle of relevance and the prohibition of hearsay evidence.

Despite the seeming conflict between customary and statutory law, there are instances where customary law can override statutory law.

Here are some circumstances where this can occur:

1. If a statute expressly recognizes customary law as a source of law, the court may apply customary law, even if it appears to conflict with statutory law.
   
   
2. If the custom in question has been so widely and consistently applied in the community or locality, the court may be compelled to apply it, even if it seems to conflict with the letter or spirit of the statute. In other words, the practice may have crystallized into law over time.
   
   
3. If the language of the statute is ambiguous, the court may resolve the ambiguity in favor of customary law that is consistent with the underlying principles of the legislation.

Furthermore, customary law plays a vital role in Nigeria’s legal system, and its influence extends beyond the formal legal system. However, this influence is not absolute, and sometimes conflicts with statutory law. The courts have developed several principles to balance the competing claims of customary and statutory law in Nigerian jurisprudence. The challenge is to maintain the delicate balance between recognition of customs and safeguarding human rights within the larger legal framework.

Read: Corporate Law in Nigeria: Opportunities and Challenges

Explore Further: Environmental Laws in Nigeria: Protecting Nature’s Rights

Conclusion

Customary law plays a crucial role in the Nigerian legal system by reflecting the values, beliefs, and traditions of the people.

Its application promotes access to justice in rural areas and culturally sensitive dispute resolution. We should adopt a balanced approach to its application, avoiding conflicts with statutory laws.

Customary law must not be used to justify acts contrary to statutory laws or human rights. Therefore, it is necessary to harmonize the legal system, ensuring customary law operates within the framework of statutory laws.

Continuous education on rights and the legal system is vital to prevent ignorance undermining its effectiveness.

In summary, while customary law remains relevant, we must strike a balance to uphold human rights within the framework of statutory laws.